KidVid Tournament 2008: Orange Sherbet vs. Eric Herman

Leading off the KidVid Tournament 2008 is a matchup from the Woody Guthrie Region -- the #2 seed "Campfire Song" from Orange Sherbet with help from Hot Buttered Rum (off their Campfire Sing-Along CD versus the #3 seed "My Lucky Day" from Eric Herman (off Snow Day!).

Vote in the comments below. One per family, please. Votes due by 9 PM West Coast time.

"Campfire Song" - Orange Sherbet with Hot Buttered Rum

Watch here (broadband link here)

"My Lucky Day" - Eric Herman

Comments

[Jill]

Eric Herman, easy choice.

[debinsf]

They're both so sweet and lo-tech. Dig.

My Lucky Day gets our vote.

[Josephine]

I vote for "Campfire Song." "My Lucky Day" made me smile (& it's a nice surprise ending after the credits), but I'm a sucker for woodland animals and campfires. I liked how they each had a buddy. :)

[SPark]

Put down one more vote for "My Lucky Day" it really is very cute.

[Brian D]

Two kids in my house, one vote each for Campfire Song and Lucky Day. The littlest liked Campfire Song and the oldest liked My Lucky Day.

[David]

Both are excellent but My Lucky Day gets the edge for animation and shining optimism. Tough choice.

[Gabe (5) and Milo (2.5)]

Two whalopping kid votes for "Campfire Song" by Orange Sherbet with Hot Buttered Rum! We're big sherbet fans! ( ;

[Ronnie Sharpe]

My votes is for "Campfire Song." Fun animation and aweseome vocals. My young daughter gives the vote for Campfire Song too - can't get better then that.

[Gil]

Definitely Orange Sherbet with Hot Buttered Rum!!!!

[ian mitchell]

I vote for Campfire Song as my kids just love that one.

[Lisa]

They're both great, but our household is voting for Campfire Song...

[jumango]

Campfire Song. Brings back nostalgia for the campfires and great outdoors of childhood. Great song with a great sound. And part of a GREAT album!

[Huffles]

"Campfire Song"I just loved drawings and the variety of instruments... especially the fiddle.

[rachel H]

campfire song. we love it!

[Henry]

I like the Campfire Song a whole lot. It had a good ending, not like the other one where he is stuck in the hole.

Henry, age 4

[Myles]

One vote here for "Campfire Song." Love 'em both but I'm a huge fan of Orange Sherbet and Hot Buttered Rum!

Myles

[Trisha]

Campfire Song !!!

[Jennifer Cormier]

My vote is for Campfire Song by Orange Sherbert

[gillian fynn]

Our household votes for "Campfire Song" by Orange Sherbet. Love the mellow pace of the song and the creature visuals.gillian & gary

[lennlee Keep]

Orange Sherbet for us please!

[esther]

CAMPFIRE SONG - AWE-SOME!! We listen to it (and the whole CD, in fact) over & over....

[Kathy Shepherd]

We love "Campfire Song"! Go Orange Sherbet!!!

Kathy, ChaCha & Ceci

[steve pokorny]

Lucky day is nice but Campfire song is just AWESOME! Sherbet all the way.

[Fiona]

We vote for orange sherbet please!

[Libee Uhuru]

Campfire Song! Love OS & HBR...thanks!